Tartar, also known as dental calculus, often evokes a negative reaction, and rightfully so. It’s that hardened plaque that stubbornly clings to our teeth, a gritty reminder of less-than-perfect oral hygiene. Dental professionals constantly warn us about its detrimental effects, linking it to gum disease, cavities, and even tooth loss. However, could there possibly be any silver lining, any benefits, to this seemingly universally reviled substance? While overwhelmingly detrimental, a closer look reveals a few, very limited, and scientifically nuanced aspects that could be interpreted as providing some indirect information.
Understanding Tartar: The Good, the Bad, and the Calcified
Tartar is essentially calcified dental plaque. Plaque, a sticky film of bacteria, food debris, and saliva, constantly forms on our teeth. If plaque isn’t removed regularly through brushing and flossing, it hardens over time into tartar. This hardening process is due to the deposition of minerals from saliva, primarily calcium and phosphate.
The formation of tartar is a natural process, but its accumulation is accelerated by poor oral hygiene, a diet high in sugars and starches, and certain individual predispositions. Once tartar forms, it’s incredibly difficult to remove with regular brushing alone, requiring professional cleaning by a dentist or dental hygienist.
The most common perception of tartar is negative. It is a porous substance that provides a rough surface for even more plaque to accumulate. This creates a vicious cycle, accelerating the progression of oral diseases.
The Detrimental Effects of Tartar
Tartar’s primary impact is on oral health. It contributes to:
- Gingivitis: The inflammation of the gums caused by bacteria in plaque and tartar. Gums become red, swollen, and bleed easily.
- Periodontitis: An advanced form of gum disease where the inflammation extends to the bone and tissues supporting the teeth, potentially leading to tooth loss.
- Cavities: Tartar provides a haven for bacteria that produce acids, eroding tooth enamel and leading to cavities.
- Bad Breath (Halitosis): The porous nature of tartar traps food particles and bacteria, contributing to unpleasant breath.
- Staining: Tartar can become stained by food, drinks (coffee, tea, red wine), and tobacco, leading to unsightly discoloration of the teeth.
Given these significant drawbacks, it’s hard to imagine any redeeming qualities. However, within certain limited scientific contexts, some aspects of its formation can provide specific information.
The Shadow of Benefit: Rare, Indirect, and Scientific Interpretations
It’s crucial to emphasize that the term “benefit” is used cautiously here. These aspects are not direct advantages of having tartar but rather, in some very specific situations, might provide insights or information. Under no circumstances should this be interpreted as an endorsement of allowing tartar to accumulate.
Paleopathological Insights: A Glimpse into the Past
One area where tartar provides some benefit is in the field of paleopathology, the study of ancient diseases. Tartar, being a calcified substance, can persist on teeth for centuries, even millennia.
-
Dietary Analysis: Tartar can trap microscopic food particles, such as starch grains and plant fibers. By analyzing these trapped remnants, researchers can gain insights into the diets of past populations. This can reveal information about their agricultural practices, food processing techniques, and overall nutritional status. This information helps us understand how diet impacted the health and development of past civilizations.
-
Ancient DNA Analysis: Tartar can also trap ancient DNA from bacteria, viruses, and even human cells. Analyzing this DNA can provide information about the diseases that affected past populations, their genetic relationships, and even the evolution of certain pathogens. The study of ancient diseases offers crucial insights into how infectious diseases have evolved and spread throughout human history.
-
Oral Microbiome Studies: By analyzing the microbial composition of ancient tartar, researchers can reconstruct the oral microbiomes of past populations. This can shed light on how our oral microbiomes have changed over time and how these changes relate to shifts in diet, lifestyle, and environmental factors. This historical perspective can provide valuable context for understanding the complex relationship between the oral microbiome and human health today.
However, these benefits are purely scientific and historical. They don’t translate into any advantages for individuals living today.
Potential for Forensic Odontology: Identification Aid
In the field of forensic odontology (the application of dental science to legal investigations), tartar, while problematic, can sometimes offer limited assistance in identifying individuals.
-
Rough Surface for DNA Retention: The porous and rough surface of tartar can trap DNA, potentially providing a source of genetic material for identification purposes, especially in cases where other tissues are degraded. This is particularly relevant in cases of unidentified remains or mass disasters.
-
Dietary and Geographic Markers: Similar to paleopathological studies, the composition of tartar can sometimes provide clues about an individual’s diet and geographic origin. This information can be used to narrow down the pool of potential candidates for identification. These markers, while not definitive, can be valuable pieces of evidence in forensic investigations.
It’s important to note that relying solely on tartar for identification is unreliable. Other, more accurate methods, such as DNA analysis from bone or teeth, are preferred.
A Very Weak “Barrier” Argument: Misguided Justification
Some people mistakenly believe that tartar acts as a barrier, protecting teeth from decay. This is entirely false. While tartar is hard, it’s also porous, providing a haven for bacteria and actually promoting decay.
-
Porous and Permeable: Tartar is not an impenetrable shield. Its porous nature allows acids produced by bacteria to penetrate and erode tooth enamel. This permeability makes teeth more susceptible to decay, not less.
-
Increased Plaque Accumulation: The rough surface of tartar provides an ideal surface for plaque to accumulate. This increases the concentration of bacteria and acids in contact with the tooth surface, accelerating the decay process. This accumulation negates any theoretical protective effect.
This misconception is dangerous because it can lead people to neglect their oral hygiene, believing that tartar is somehow beneficial. In reality, the presence of tartar always indicates a need for professional cleaning and improved oral hygiene practices.
Prioritizing Prevention and Professional Care
The limited and indirect “benefits” of tartar do not outweigh the significant risks it poses to oral health. The focus should always be on preventing tartar formation through diligent oral hygiene practices:
- Brushing: Brush your teeth at least twice a day with fluoride toothpaste, paying attention to all surfaces of the teeth.
- Flossing: Floss daily to remove plaque and food particles from between your teeth and along the gumline.
- Mouthwash: Use an antiseptic mouthwash to kill bacteria and freshen your breath.
- Professional Cleanings: Visit your dentist or dental hygienist regularly for professional cleanings to remove plaque and tartar buildup.
- Dietary Modifications: Limit your intake of sugary and starchy foods and drinks, which contribute to plaque formation.
Regular dental checkups and professional cleanings are essential for maintaining optimal oral health and preventing the buildup of tartar. Dentists and dental hygienists have the tools and expertise to remove tartar safely and effectively, helping to prevent gum disease, cavities, and other oral health problems. They can also provide personalized advice on how to improve your oral hygiene practices and maintain a healthy smile.
Conclusion: The Overwhelming Truth About Tartar
While tartar can provide some limited and indirect benefits in specific scientific contexts like paleopathology and forensic odontology, its detrimental effects on oral health far outweigh any potential advantages. Tartar promotes gum disease, cavities, bad breath, and tooth staining. The focus should always be on preventing tartar formation through diligent oral hygiene practices and regular professional cleanings. Prioritizing prevention and professional care is the key to maintaining a healthy and beautiful smile.
Is tartar the same as plaque?
No, tartar and plaque are distinct, though related, substances. Plaque is a soft, sticky film composed of bacteria, food debris, and saliva that constantly forms on your teeth. It’s relatively easy to remove with daily brushing and flossing. If plaque isn’t removed, it hardens over time into tartar, also known as dental calculus.
Tartar is a hardened deposit that binds strongly to the teeth, making it much more difficult to remove than plaque. Unlike plaque, tartar requires professional cleaning by a dentist or dental hygienist. The formation of tartar provides a rough surface that encourages further plaque buildup, creating a vicious cycle.
What are the usual negative effects of tartar?
Tartar’s primary negative effect is its creation of a rough surface where plaque can accumulate more easily. This increased plaque buildup contributes to a higher risk of developing gum disease (gingivitis and periodontitis), tooth decay (cavities), and bad breath (halitosis). Tartar itself doesn’t directly cause these problems but rather creates an environment that fosters their development.
Furthermore, the presence of tartar can lead to inflammation of the gums, causing them to become red, swollen, and bleed easily. In advanced cases, this can lead to periodontitis, a serious gum infection that can damage the soft tissue and bone supporting the teeth, potentially resulting in tooth loss. The unsightly appearance of tartar can also affect one’s self-esteem.
Does tartar offer any benefits at all?
While primarily detrimental, some studies suggest that, in very specific and limited contexts, tartar might offer a minor protective effect. For example, some researchers theorize that tartar, by covering the tooth surface, could potentially act as a physical barrier against acid erosion from dietary acids or gastric reflux. This protection is, however, minimal and significantly outweighed by the negative consequences of tartar buildup.
Another proposed benefit is that analyzing the composition of ancient tartar (dental calculus) can provide valuable insights into the diets, health, and lifestyles of past populations. This analysis can reveal information about the types of food consumed, the presence of disease-causing organisms, and even exposure to environmental toxins. This, however, is an archaeological benefit and not a personal health benefit.
How can I prevent tartar buildup?
The cornerstone of preventing tartar buildup is diligent oral hygiene practices. This includes brushing your teeth twice a day with fluoride toothpaste for at least two minutes each time, paying close attention to all surfaces of your teeth. Regular flossing, ideally once a day, is equally important to remove plaque and food particles from between your teeth and along the gumline, areas that a toothbrush may miss.
In addition to brushing and flossing, using an antimicrobial mouthwash can help reduce the bacteria in your mouth that contribute to plaque formation. It’s also crucial to schedule regular dental checkups and cleanings with your dentist or dental hygienist. Professional cleanings remove any existing tartar and allow your dentist to identify and address any potential problems early on.
Are some people more prone to tartar buildup than others?
Yes, certain individuals are more susceptible to tartar buildup due to various factors. Saliva composition plays a significant role; some people’s saliva contains higher levels of minerals like calcium and phosphate, which contribute to the hardening of plaque into tartar. Dietary habits, such as consuming sugary or starchy foods frequently, can also increase the amount of plaque and, consequently, tartar formation.
Furthermore, individuals with poor oral hygiene practices, such as infrequent brushing and flossing, are at a higher risk. Certain medical conditions, such as dry mouth (xerostomia), can also contribute to tartar buildup because saliva helps to wash away food particles and neutralize acids in the mouth. Genetic predisposition may also play a role, making some people naturally more prone to tartar than others.
What happens during a professional tartar removal procedure?
A professional tartar removal procedure, also known as scaling, is performed by a dentist or dental hygienist. They use specialized instruments, such as scalers and ultrasonic devices, to carefully remove tartar deposits from the surfaces of your teeth, both above and below the gumline. The process is typically painless, although some individuals may experience mild sensitivity, especially if they have gum inflammation.
After scaling, the dentist or hygienist may perform root planing, which involves smoothing the surfaces of the tooth roots to prevent further plaque and tartar accumulation. Polishing the teeth follows to remove any remaining stains and leave the surfaces feeling smooth. In some cases, an antimicrobial rinse or medication may be applied to the gums to promote healing and reduce inflammation.
Can I remove tartar at home?
No, tartar cannot be effectively removed at home using over-the-counter products or home remedies. Once plaque has hardened into tartar, it forms a strong bond with the tooth surface that only professional dental instruments can break. Attempting to remove tartar yourself with sharp objects can damage your teeth and gums, potentially leading to infection and further complications.
While you can’t remove existing tartar at home, maintaining excellent oral hygiene is crucial for preventing its formation in the first place. Regular brushing, flossing, and using antimicrobial mouthwash are essential for removing plaque before it hardens into tartar. Regular dental checkups and cleanings are also necessary for professional tartar removal and early detection of any potential problems.